I voted for the second one but both were done really well. In the first one, the background is pretty sweet and it works really well with the form Sora is in. That render of Sora is very nice to. The second one, while to me it does seem like just a gradient with a little brushing and Sora on top, came out really well. The colors work really nicely with the Oathkeeper and the Oblivion, I like what that sig had going on in that.